- The Supreme Court will decide whether a Mexican family can sue a U.S. Border Patrol agent in an American court for the shooting death of Sergio Hernandez.
- The agent, Jesus Mesa, was standing in the United States when he discharged his weapon and killed Hernandez, who was on Mexican soil.
- The federal appeals courts are divided as to whether such lawsuits can proceed.
The Supreme Court announced Tuesday that it will decide whether a Mexican family can sue a Border Patrol agent for the 2010 cross-border shooting death of Sergio Adrian Hernandez Guereca.
Hernandez, a 15-year-old Mexican national, was on Mexican soil when Border Patrol agent Jesus Mesa shot and killed him while standing in the U.S. The justices will decide whether the Hernandez family can sue Mesa in an American court.
“When agents of the United States government violate fundamental rights of Mexican nationals and others within Mexico’s jurisdiction, it is a priority to Mexico to see that the United States has provided adequate means to hold the agents accountable and to compensate the victims,” the Mexican government told the high court in legal briefs.
Lawyers for Hernandez’s family say he and several friends were playing a game in the border culvert separating El Paso, Texas from Ciudad Juarez at the time of the shooting. The Department of Justice counters that the shooting happened as Mesa intercepted a group of smugglers attempting to enter the U.S. illegally, who then hurled rocks at him. Cellphone video contests the government’s version of events.
Federal prosecutors declined to bring charges against Mesa, after investigators reviewed the shooting as a possible homicide. Hernandez’s death was also investigated for civil rights violations. Mexico asked the federal government to extradite Mesa, but the Obama administration refused.
The case first reached the Supreme Court in 2017, but the justices punted and sent the dispute back to the 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals for further review.
The 5th Circuit found against the Hernandez family the second time around, stressing that Congress has not authorized the kind of lawsuit the family is bringing. The Supreme Court said in a 1971 decision called Bivens v. Six Unknown Named Agents that individuals can sue federal officials for a violation of constitutional rights even without express authorization from Congress. The Hernandez family wants to sue Mesa under the Bivens decision.